Christopher Camisa rented a car from Nissan of Stanhope and failed to return it on Dec. 16, Byram Township Police said.
Camisa was then caught driving the car — which had since been registered as stolen — in Parsippany on Jan. 12, police said.
Camisa was arrested, charged with theft of a motor vehicle and released pending an appearance in Sussex County Superior Court.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Morris and receive free news updates.